I recently carried out a survey about women's fiction and the 132 responses made for fascinating reading.
There were the ordinary, useful questions about reading habits and demographic etc, but as a writer, what interested me most were the responses to questions I posed about the nitty-gritty of the writing, because this gave me a real flavour of what makes people read a book compulsively.
One of the questions asked respondents to choose statements about women's fiction they agreed with, and to add some of their own. Many people went on to make some very interesting and insightful suggestions, and I really wanted to share these results with you.
So, to start off with, here are the responses to the statements I provided myself:
It's important that I care what happens to the main character in a book and almost feel as if the events of the story are happening to me. 75.76%
I like to feel extremes of emotion when I'm reading - both happy and sad. 55.3%
When I'm reading, I enjoy being taken to places and experiencing situations I've never experience before. 76.52%
I'm happy for a novel to include an element of magic, or events that might never happen in real life, as long as the author makes me believe in it. 57.58%
A romance of some kind is essential in a book in order for me to enjoy it. 17.42%
I like a book's main character to grow and to learn something during the story. 63.64%
A book must have a happy ending, otherwise I feel cheated. 10.61%
It's not a problem to me if the main character is someone I don't particularly like. 39.39%
I like to feel I have something in common with the main protagonist. 25%
And here are the statements that respondents added themselves - the ingredients and factors that are important to them in a satisfying women's fiction novel.
- I don't like loose ends, need to know what happened to all characters
- Furthering women's causes
- It has to feel realistic and not too cliched.
- Not too far fetched...
- Needs to grab you in the first chapter, dialogue is important
- Well written prose.
- It doesn't always have to have sex. Geez already.
- Anything to keep me interested and page turning. A good storyline.
- Helps me learn or appreciate something new
- I like some humour
- If I'm not supposed to like a main character, I need something bad to happen to them.
- The main character should have some kind of intelligence, I get bored by ditzy girls, they have to be smart or witty or work things out
- A good beginning that draws me in!
- A sense of suspending disbelief or of an idealised reality being portrayed- country cottage, independent woman, seaside etc
- Location. Books,based in a city with a bit of a story about the city interest me.
- That the supporting characters are also fleshed out and have a story
- The characters and their responses to situations must be believable.
- Inner conflict
- Good quality prose
- Intelligence. Please expect that I am intelligent and need brain stimulation.
- I prefer heroines who aren't weak, who can save themselves or others
- Humor is so essential for me to thoroughly enjoy an MC or supporting characters. A book needs to take me away from the BS of everyday stress, the new and political mumbo jumbo. It needs to be a true, enjoyable or fascinatingly interesting escape!
- Great characterization and good writing is a key
- I am discouraged with novels crammed with over detailed descriptions of superficial things
- Well written with relatable 3-dimensional characters
- Good writing with realistic dialogue. An element of truth in the theme that I can relate to.
- Right or wrong, that she be strong 🙂 (#StrongWomenWrite hashtag on Twitter)
- Needs to be believable, must like the hero or heroine and care about them.
- The author doesn't insult my intelligence by telling me everything.
- Expect the unexpected
- I love to get into the mind of the character - and I like novels with suspense, ie. Gone Girl. I am more interested in the writing and how the writer creates rich and complicated characters.
- Words chosen in writing should be easily understood by most people. Grammar is very important.
- No misogynistic cliches please. I'm so fed up with Women as victims. Women don't need men to rescue them. They don't have to be superhuman - just real!
To sum up, (and this is my interpretation of the results) most people want a strong character who draws us in because we're intrigued, and prepared to invest in finding out what happens to them. We might be prepared to suspend our disbelief in the process, but we want to have our intelligence respected. We also want to have work to do - to have things to work out, and that actively engage our imaginations and our thoughts. We don't want to be handed everything on a plate like a bland meal, but we're happy to be entertained. We want good-quality ingredients, but a novel doesn't need to be so good for us it feels like a meal we eat when we're on our best behaviour.
I'm so grateful to everyone who took my survey. Their answers have really given me an insight into what people want from a great women's fiction novel. I'm off to apply all the advice!
Bye for now.